June 7, 2023

Florida’s largest employer, The Walt Disney Firm, and Governor Ron DeSantis are presently embroiled in a unending, no-win dispute. With DeSantis making ready to announce his marketing campaign for president of the US, it’s straightforward to take sides for political causes, however harmful to leap to conclusions with out totally understanding the roots of the controversy.

Listed here are 5 classes firms should study from this dispute:

There are not any state subsidies with out implicit quid professional quos

In July 2021, Disney’s new CEO Bob Chapek introduced the corporate would transfer its theme park headquarters and a pair of,000 workers from Burbank, California to Lake Nona Florida, investing $864 million in its new workplace complicated.

In trade, DeSantis agreed that Disney would obtain $578 million in tax breaks from the state of Florida. Little question DeSantis felt betrayed the next March when Chapek publicly attacked his Parental Rights in Schooling Act. What implicit understanding did Chapek have with DeSantis?

In right this moment’s world, CEOs are anticipated to talk out on behalf of their workers, their firm’s mission, and their values.

Disney has lengthy been recognized for its energetic assist of its LGBTQ+ workers and its inclusion of LGBTQ+ characters in its motion pictures. But when Chapek grew to become CEO of Disney in February 2020, he pledged to not talk about controversial points publicly–in sharp distinction along with his predecessor Bob Iger, who deftly dealt with these points.

When you find yourself CEO of one of many world’s most seen and best-loved firms, you haven’t any selection however to take public stands on behalf of your organization’s beliefs and your workers–when these stances are core to your model. Little question you threat offending a few of your clients, however that’s the value you pay for having clear rules.

Whereas Chapek might have been an skilled operator able to producing income, he was wholly unprepared to change into CEO of one of many world’s most public firms. This isn’t uncommon. As we’ve realized in our New CEO Workshop at Harvard Enterprise Faculty, coping with complicated public points is the world the place new CEOs really feel least ready.

You’ll be able to’t change positions in midstream

Because the controversy over the Florida laws erupted, Disney workers publicly protested, even staging walkouts at Pixar. At that time, Chapek felt compelled to reverse his code of silence and issued robust statements of apology. Chatting with you, studying your messages, and assembly with you’ve got helped me higher perceive how painful our silence was,” he stated. “It’s clear that this isn’t simply a problem a couple of invoice in Florida, however as an alternative yet one more problem to primary human rights. You wanted me to be a stronger ally within the struggle for equal rights and I allow you to down. I’m sorry.”

As honest as Chapek was, Governor DeSantis smelled blood within the water and went on the assault towards Disney to additional his conservative credentials in his quest for the White Home. He took away Disney’s privileged standing within the Reedy Creek Enchancment District, taking management by changing the board along with his appointees.

Your predecessor shouldn’t have interaction publicly in these disputes

Chapek’s predecessor Bob Iger was an especially profitable CEO for 16 years, however after turning over the reins to Chapek in 2020, he ought to by no means have commented publicly on Chapek’s actions, regardless of how strongly he disagreed.

As an alternative, Iger tweeted his open support in February 2022 for President Biden’s robust opposition to the Florida laws, writing, “I’m with the President on this! If handed, this invoice will put weak, younger LGBTQ individuals in jeopardy”–thus placing himself in direct opposition to Chapek. He later bolstered his place on CNN, saying, “It’s about proper and fallacious.”

Ever the astute politician, DeSantis noticed this cut up as a possibility to interact in ever extra aggressive assaults on Disney as being “woke.”

Politicians shouldn’t assault their largest and most beloved employer

Disney already has 75,000 workers in Florida and is planning so as to add 13,000 extra because it plans to speculate a further $17 billion within the state. Each governor within the nation, Republican or Democrat, can be thrilled to have Disney make these investments of their state–besides Ron DeSantis.

Now Iger and Disney are counterattacking with a lawsuit and accusing DeSantis of orchestrating a “marketing campaign of presidency retaliation” towards the corporate that violates its first modification rights. At Disney’s annual shareholders’ assembly, Iger accused DeSantis of being “anti-business” and “anti-Florida.” Sensing the political winds are shifting towards DeSantis on this battle, Home Speaker Kevin McCarthy is urging DeSantis to “sit down and negotiate” with Disney as an alternative of waging a authorized battle towards them. As an alternative, the DeSantis-appointed tourism board countersued Disney.

In distinction, when Georgia Governor Brian Kemp and the Georgia legislature pushed by way of new voting legal guidelines in 2021, it needed to overcome robust vocal opposition from two of its largest employers, The Coca-Cola Firm and Delta Air Strains, but Kemp by no means publicly attacked the businesses.

CEOs and politicians alike ought to acknowledge the significance of resolving points privately as a result of, in a public dispute like this one, nobody wins. But many CEOs are drawing the fallacious classes, pondering they will ignore these public points. They can’t. In right this moment’s world, CEOs are anticipated to have clear public positions on points very important to their firms. In the event that they don’t, they could face the identical destiny that befell Disney’s Bob Chapek.

Invoice George is the creator of True North: Rising Chief Version, an govt fellow at Harvard Enterprise Faculty, and a former chair and CEO of Medtronic.

The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary items are solely the views of their authors and don’t essentially replicate the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.

Extra must-read commentary revealed by Fortune: